Who came up with: "the YouTube video sparked the “protest” against the U.S. in Benghazi"? (
CJR).
AIM, by Kenneth R. Timmerman, March 11, 2015:
Until Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-SC) revealed last week that his Benghazi
Select Committee was investigating Hillary Clinton’s use of a private
email server for her official State Department communications,
no one
had a good explanation for why none of the Congressional committees that
had previously investigated Benghazi had ever cited a single Hillary
Clinton email in their reports.
Congressional Democrats had been pooh-poohing Gowdy’s investigation,
claiming that all the important questions about Benghazi had been “asked
and answered” by previous committees.
Now the best that Gowdy’s counterpart, Rep. Elijah Cummings (D-MD),
can do is object to subpoenas (especially when they are issued to
Hillary Clinton in person, through Counsel), and to huff and puff about
the investigation becoming a “
surrogate” for the “Republican National Committee.”
What a change a single revelation can bring.
We now learn that Hillary Clinton not only used a private server,
maintained at her Chappaqua, New York home for official communications,
but that she never used a government email at all. Not once.
No
secretary@state.gov, or
Clinton.hr@state.gov or anything of the kind. Just
multiple accounts on her family server, clintonemail.com, including
hdr22@clintonemail.com,
the same address used by former Clinton White House aide Sidney
Blumenthal to communicate with her on Benghazi and related matters.
Federal prosecutors recently
finished up their case
against former CIA Director David Petraeus, who was conveniently forced
to resign just three days after the November 2012 elections, before he
could clarify what he knew about Benghazi. (Given that Petraeus had just
returned from a September 2, 2012 trip to Ankara, Turkey, where he had
been trying to tamp down publicity due to an arms shipment from Benghazi
to the Syrian rebels, he certainly knew a lot.)
In a widely criticized decision, they forced him to
plea bargain
one count of a misdemeanor in exchange for dropping more serious
charges. The full extent of the FBI’s case against Petraeus involved him
sharing personal, hand-written notebooks with his biographer.
Prosecutors noted that the CIA had installed a SCIF—a specialized
high-security area—in his Arlington, Virginia home where he could safely
store classified materials brought home from the CIA. That facility was
dismantled by the CIA without incident two months after Petraeus
resigned from the Agency.
The prosecutors never accused Petraeus of improperly storing U.S.
government classified materials either in the SCIF or elsewhere. Nor did
they accuse him of sending classified materials over an unsecure
server.
If they could prosecute Petraeus on one count of improperly handling
classified material (he kept those personal notebooks in a rucksack in
his attic), one can only speculate how many thousand counts of
mishandling classified information could be brought against Mrs.
Clinton. Of course, she denies having sent classified information over
her personal server, but in that case how did she communicate on
classified matters with her envoys and subordinates?
Was the private server at her residence designed, installed, and
maintained by a U.S. government security agency? Was it connected to the
government’s Secret Internet Protocol Router Network (SIPRNet) and
physically separated from the open Internet?
The Sid Blumenthal memos, sent from his AOL account to Hillary’s
private email server, suggest that this was not the case. If so, the
former Secretary of State was breaking the law—big time.
When the memos first surfaced in 2013—posted to the Internet by a
Romanian hacker known as “Guccifer” —neither the State Department nor
their purported author acknowledged their authenticity. Given that they
initially surfaced on the website of
Russia Today, Vladimir Putin’s reliably anti-American TV network, that was enough to consign them to oblivion as yet another Internet hoax.
Now we learn that former CIA official
Tyler Drumheller
apparently helped to gather the “intel” that Blumenthal sent to Hillary
on the Benghazi attacks and other political developments inside Libya.
This is extremely significant because the initial memo sent by
Blumenthal, dated September 12, 2012, cites “a sensitive source,” who
purportedly met with Libyan President Magarief shortly after the attacks
began and claimed that a YouTube video sparked the “protest” against
the U.S. diplomatic compound in Benghazi.
Magarief himself never said such a thing, although the memo is worded
to suggest that he did. He blew up when he heard Susan Rice make that
claim on the Sunday talk shows after the attack, as I write on pages 347
and 348 of
Dark Forces: The Truth About What Happened in Benghazi.
Drumheller became infamous for several earlier pieces of
disinformation. As European Division chief at the CIA’s Directorate of
Operations in 2001 and 2002, he was the one who planted the phony
evidence about the Niger uranium contract that was later used by the
media during the Valerie Plame affair to claim that George W. Bush had
“lied” about Saddam Hussein’s WMD programs. On three separate occasions,
he passed the Niger information up the food chain as validated
intelligence, when the CIA had been warned that it was not (see page 63
of my book
Shadow Warriors).
Then-CIA Director George Tenet was so fed up with Drumheller that he
spent seven full pages in his memoir debunking claims by Drumheller
regarding the defector known as CURVEBALL that Tenet said were simply
untrue.
Drumheller and Sid Blumenthal have a history together. In 2007,
Blumenthal used Drumheller as a source
to “prove” that Bush had “lied” about pre-war intelligence on Iraqi
WMD. Drumheller and Blumenthal went on to work in Hillary Clinton’s
presidential campaign in 2007 and 2008.
So was the Guccifer/Blumenthal memo intended as disinformation,
written after Hillary Clinton put out her statement on the night of the
attacks blaming them on a YouTube video? Or was it actually the source
of Hillary’s false claim about the video, written and sent by someone
on the ground in Libya who was attempting to plant the story?
Many reporters, myself included, have submitted Freedom of
Information Act requests to the State Department, asking for all
documents and communications that would show how Mrs. Clinton’s
statement came to be worded as it was finally released.
Where are all
the drafts? Who commented on them? What did it say initially? How was it
changed? By whom?
We have much of that information for the Susan Rice talking points
,
but nothing at all for Hillary Clinton’s statement on the evening of the
attacks.
Given that there is not a single mention of a protest or the YouTube
video in all the documents released to Congress, which included
real-time communications from Tripoli and Benghazi from the State
Department and CIA that night, exactly how Mrs. Clinton came up with
that idea could provide key insight into what actually happened in
Benghazi, and why?
Related:
THE HUMA INITIATIVE: Hillary's Two Top Aides, Including HUMA ABEDIN, Also Used Private Servers - And What That Means